Are pre-workouts dangerous for your health?

Pre-workout dietary supplements are becoming increasingly popular in the world of sport, particularly bodybuilding. 

However, their heterogeneous composition, which varies from one product to another, raises questions about their safety and real effectiveness. These supplements, which are supposed to improve physical performance and mental concentration, do not present any major dangers when used as recommended, but their composition, which is sometimes a little crazy, deserves to be studied. 

While certain ingredients, such as caffeine, have been shown to have beneficial effects on energy and muscular endurance, other components are superfluous or even harmful in the long term.

To truly understand the impact of these supplements on health and performance, it is essential to analyze their various components, their dosages and their potential interactions with the body. This is what we propose to do in the remainder of this article.

Pre-workout, a vague formula

As we said in the introduction, the term "pre-workout" has become popular in the world of sports nutrition, but paradoxically its definition remains surprisingly imprecise. 

These dietary supplements, which are supposed to improve physical performance before training, have extremely variable compositions from one brand to another, with no real standardization of their formula.

Manufacturers offer widely differing combinations of active ingredients, making it difficult to compare products objectively. 

Unfortunately, some manufacturers prefer attractive marketing formulas to compositions based on solid scientific evidence. This situation makes detailed analysis of the various components found in these supplements all the more important.

To better understand the real impact of these products on sports performance and health, it's vital to examine in detail the main ingredients that make up these formulas and their respective effects on the body, so as to know the dangers of consuming them.

Focus on the ingredients of a pre-workout

Pre-workouts generally contain a host of ingredients designed to enhance sporting performance. Let's take a scientific look at each of them (statistically the most widely used) to understand their real relevance.

BCAA (branched-chain amino acids)

BCAAs play an important role in protein synthesis and muscle recovery, particularly when present in supplements such as whey protein. The latter can be particularly useful for mass gain and post-workout recovery. 

However, their presence in pre-workouts has no scientific basis. Consuming them in isolation before exercise brings no immediate performance benefits. What's more, their utilization by the body is recognized to be far more effective when consumed as part of a biologically complete protein, rather than in isolation.

Caffeine

Caffeine is the most scientifically relevant ingredient in pre-workouts. It improves mental concentration and physical performance⁽¹⁾in some people. The optimal dosage for per os intake, i.e. in a drinkable solution, is between 3 and 6 mg per kg of body weight, i.e. around 200-400 mg for an average adult. 

Taurine

Although taurine is often associated with improved performance, scientific evidence for its efficacy as a single dose is limited. Its use in pre-workouts does not necessarily seem relevant.

Creatine

Creatine is an effective supplement for increasing muscle strength and performance, but its use in pre-workouts is inappropriate. Its effectiveness relies on muscle saturation achieved through regular supplementation (5g per day for several weeks). A single intake before training is of no physiological benefit. We even recommend taking creatine post-exercise rather than pre-exercise, to improve its absorption. Remember that creatine has no effect on the day it is taken.

Beta-Alanine

Like creatine, beta-alanine requires chronic supplementation (4-6g per day for several weeks) to be effective. Its presence in pre-workouts can cause skin tingling (paresthesia), sometimes sought after by athletes, but without bringing the expected and recognized benefits directly on the ensuing effort.

Vitamins and other components

The various vitamins, minerals and other added components generally lack any scientific basis in terms of their efficacy when taken on an occasional basis. Their dosage is often imprecise, and their presence is more a matter of marketing strategy than of real nutritional interest.

To clearly summarize the effectiveness and relevance of each ingredient in pre-workouts, here's a summary table:

Conclusion

In conclusion, in-depth analysis of pre-workouts reveals that their growing popularity does not necessarily reflect their real effectiveness. The majority of the ingredients present in these preparations lack solid scientific foundations or are poorly dosed for occasional use prior to physical training.

Only caffeine has been shown to have tangible benefits on sports performance, provided that recommended dosages are respected and over-consumption is avoided, which can lead to side-effects such as heart palpitations, sleep disorders or high blood pressure.

Beware, too, of secondary ingredients (additives, sweeteners, etc.) and potential cross-contamination with undesirable products.

For athletes looking to improve their performance naturally and safely, it's best to focus on a balanced diet, adequate hydration and a regular sleep cycle. Should the use of supplements prove necessary, it is advisable to favor products with simple, transparent formulas and, if necessary, to consult a competent health professional in this field to avoid any risks associated with misuse.

Sources