Soy lecithin, an emulsifier widely used in the agri-food industry, is now raising questions about its effects on human health, particularly among athletes concerned about their diet.
While emulsifiers in general are increasingly being criticized for their potential negative impact - particularly on cardiovascular disease - the specific case of soy lecithin has yet to be studied, and data are lacking to conclude that it is a proven danger.
However, regular consumption of products containing soy lecithin, often extracted from intensively farmed or GMO seeds, raises questions about the presence of chemical residues, the risk of allergy, and even side effects in sensitive individuals.
After defining what an emulsifier is and reviewing the general dangers of these agents, this article will look at soy lecithin, its origins, composition, potential risks and the precautions to be considered for a healthy diet adapted to sports practice.
Emulsifiers: who are they? Are they dangerous?
Emulsifiers are food additives, often of plant or animal origin, used to stabilize mixtures between immiscible substances, such as water and fats or proteins, and to improve the texture, preservation and appearance of industrial foods.
They are found in a wide variety of everyday food products: chocolate, margarine, cream, flavored milk, cookies, protein-based dietary supplements (whey), and many ultra-processed foods. Among the most commonly used emulsifiers are celluloses (E460-E468), mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids (E471, E472), lecithins (notably of soy, sunflower or rapeseed), gums, phosphates and pectins.
The daily consumption of foods containing emulsifiers has become widespread, particularly in countries where industrial food and mass production based on soy, vegetable oil or fats are commonplace.
This regular exposure raises questions about the safety of these substances, especially as their presence is often associated with products derived from intensive agriculture or containing GMO soy derivatives, which may imply the presence of pesticide residues or other chemical molecules.
From a scientific point of view(1), several recent studies have highlighted an association between high emulsifier consumption and an increased risk of cardiovascular disease, particularly coronary and cerebrovascular disease.
The results show that people who regularly consume large quantities of celluloses, mono- and diglycerides of fatty acids or certain phosphates have an increased risk of cardiovascular events.
The mechanisms put forward include disruption of intestinal microbiota, increased chronic inflammation and a deleterious impact on metabolic health, all of which are of particular concern to sportsmen and women concerned with preserving their cardiovascular health and performance.
Although not all emulsifiers have the same risk profile, and hazard levels vary from molecule to molecule, all the available data suggest caution.
It is important to note that in the study presented(1), emulsifier hazard levels were not found for lecithins and carrageenans.
To limit the impact of these food additives, we recommend that you opt for a natural diet, check the composition of your food and avoid over-consumption of industrial products, especially for athletes looking for dietary supplements or soy- or milk-based proteins.
The next part of this article will look at the special case of soy lecithin, an emulsifier widely used in protein powders, in order to assess its risks and specific features in greater detail.
The special case of soy lecithin (especially in whey)
Soy lecithin is a natural emulsifier (the famous ones mentioned above) widely used in the food industry, notably as a texturizing agent in protein powders such as whey. Its main function is to improve the miscibility of powders in water and prevent foaming when preparing shakers.
However, despite its widespread use, the scientific data available on the specific risks associated with soy lecithin consumption remains limited and insufficient to conclude that there is no, or a proven, danger to human health.
Nevertheless, it's important to note that the majority of industrial lecithins come from genetically modified soya, often grown in South America, which raises questions about the potential presence of pesticide or solvent residues used during extraction.
For people allergic to soy, lecithin can cause reactions, although the risk is lower than with pure soy protein.
Beyond the health aspects, just as the production of industrial whey is open to debate, that of soy raises serious environmental and ethical questions. Intensive soybean cultivation, particularly in Brazil and Argentina, is one of the main causes of deforestation, loss of biodiversity and massive CO2 emissions. It is also associated with intensive pesticide use and land grabbing, impacting local populations and ecosystem health.
In view of these uncertainties and the absence of any proven nutritional benefit from soy lecithin in whey, we advise you to choose products free from additives, emulsifiers and sweeteners, and sourced locally and transparently.
Whey protein
Formula developed by qualified pharmacists 🔬
- Manufactured in-house by Protéalpes
- No additives, no sweeteners
- Protein isolate from Rhône-Alpes
Available in packs of 3 to 4.5 kg
Alternatives exist, such as the lecithin-free whey offered by Protéalpes, which guarantees a simple, natural and environmentally-friendly composition. This choice avoids unnecessary exposure to substances whose long-term impact is not fully known, while supporting more ethical and sustainable production.
To preserve your health and limit your impact on the environment, it's best to check the composition of your food supplements and favor local sources, with NO additives.
Conclusion
In conclusion, soy lecithin remains an ingredient whose effects on human health still require in-depth study. Current data show that soy lecithin, in moderate quantities and from organic sources, does not present a proven risk for the majority of the population, according to EFSA and other European food safety authorities.
The environment is not left out: the intensive cultivation of soy, often genetically modified and associated with the use of pesticides, contributes to deforestation, loss of biodiversity and a growing carbon footprint. Opting for alternatives such as additive-free whey, and preferring organic and/or local products, helps limit exposure to toxic substances and reduce the environmental impact of our diet.
